Thoughts On The Bright Side of Life by Émile Zola

Photograph by Pete Halewood of Barton-on-Sea

Life. Happiness. Depression. Responsibility. Love. Sacrifice. Boredom. Isolation. Charity. Jealousy. Purpose. Disappointment. Resilience. Pain.

Those are the words that came to me when I asked myself what the novel The Bright Side of Life by Émile Zola was about. The original French title is Le Joie de Vivre, and is also commonly known in english as ‘The Joy of Living’. To be honest, I’m not a big fan of the Oxford World’s Classics english title The Bright Side of Life (translated by Andrew Rothwell). It is too close for me to the Monty Python song Always Look on the Bright Side of Life, which I see no relevance to at all with the novel, and only serves to get the song stuck in my head every time I think of those words. But hey, it is what it is, and the translator has every right to name it how they wish.

Published in 1884, it is the 12th novel of Émile Zola’s Les Rougon-Macquart cycle, and is for me the most unique and isolated of the novels I have read so far. It is set in a coastal village in Normandy, and makes very few references to the characters or events in other Rougon-Macquart novels. Zola wanted his Rougon-Macquart novels to be a study of french life during the Second Empire (1852-1870), but whilst this novel is definitely a study, there is little to connect it to the Second Empire. But more on that later.

So, The Bright Side of Life, this is going to be a cheery book, hey? Keep me fuzzy and warm during the increasingly depressing events of 2020, surely? Well………how do I break this to you? No. Not really. Or…..it’s complicated. Yes, it’s complicated. That’s probably more accurate.

Joy definitely creeps up every now and then throughout the novel, and there are some lovely thoughts on joy and happiness, but the novel runs through a sea of disappointment, struggle and despair, again and again. I deliberately said ‘sea’ there because the sea is a key character and feature of the novel. Life in the novel takes place right next to the sea. Set in the fictitious town called Bonneville (‘Goodtown’ – Zola is definitely messing with us), the sea helps the characters create lasting bonds, provides joy, and destroys at the same time.

The central character in the novel is Pauline Quenu, previously featured in the 1873 novel The Belly of Paris (Le Ventre de Paris). She is now a 10 year old orphan, who has been adopted by her uncle and auntie, Monsier and Madame Chanteau, and by doing so, leaves Paris for the Normandy coast. She has been left with a sizeable inheritance, which causes jealousy, unrest and scheming within the household.

The Chanteau’s have a son called Lazare, who by my reckoning is 9 years older than Pauline, but they strike up a very profound and deep friendship. They regularly explore the area by the sea together in playful dalliances, and Pauline takes an interest in the many passing schemes and interests of Lazare. From becoming a maestro pianist, to extracting valuable minerals from seaweed, to saving the town from the sea by building coastal defences, Lazare’s interests are many and fleeting at the same time.

Whilst not a thriller in any sense of the word (this is a Zola novel), it is an incredibly charming novel, and in Pauline, has one of Zola’s greatest and most lovable characters to appear in any of the Rougon-Macquart novels. She is always thinking of others before herself (though this may occasionally slip); financing their plans and ambitions, helping the local poverty-stricken children, and being a nurse to Monsier Chanteau, who suffers from regular debilitating bouts of gout, often brought on by his lack of discipline in refraining from foods he knows will bring on an attack. Pauline becomes the only person who can ease Chanteau’s pain, and therefore becomes indispensable to him.

She is not so kindly looked on by Madame Chanteau, who though initially appreciative of Pauline’s positive influence on the household, begins to become irritated and accuses her to others of being selfish. She helps herself to Pauline’s fortune, all the while knowing that Pauline will not fight hard to protect something, she does not give much value to in life.

The final character in the household, is the long serving (and suffering) maid, Véronique. Not delighted at first with Pauline’s presence in the household, she becomes much more appreciative and warm towards Pauline, when she notices how she gets taken advantage of by the others. The treatment of Pauline becomes an increasing frustration to her.

There are regular visitors to the household; Doctor Cazenove, whose frequent and unsocial hours requirements at the Chanteau’s must make him one of the most sleep deprived doctors that can be found, the local priest Abbé Horteur, providing often ignored spiritual guidance, and most importantly, a young girl named Louise who becomes a key factor on the development between the relationship between Pauline and Lazare.

Though hard to determine exactly how long, the novel takes place over a period of at least 15 years. This would mean the timeline of the novel runs from about 1863 to well into the 1870’s, years after the french defeat in the Franco-Prussian war, and long after the end of the Second Empire.

This is important, because these events are not referred to in the novel at all, as they are in Nana and The Debacle. Therefore, I believe isolation is a key theme of this novel, as world events seem to take place, without any knowledge or care by this coastal community. The novel easily could have been set either 40 years earlier or after, and it still could be the same.

The characters all struggle to break free from this isolated household and community, and often the ones that manage to, always end up coming back. It indeeds seems that death is the only way out…..

Mental health also seems to be a key theme of the novel, long before it was a term and concern in modern society. It shows to me, as with other classic books, that often the struggles we have today have actually always been around and reflected upon by great minds.

Lazare is a particular focus of mental well-being, and from reading the descriptions of his behaviour, it seems clear that he suffers from anxiety disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, and almost certainly bipolar disorder as well. This manifests in his increasing boredom with the world and his terrible fear of death (thanatophobia). He is a cynical and hopeless character, but is often distracted by his latest scheme and plan for his life, as brief as it may turn out.

I have to admit that I did see some of myself in Lazare’s character. Not his awful depression or fear of death, but in his struggle to stay focussed on one particular purpose in life, and his constant shifting of ideas and projects to stay stimulated. I’m not nihilistic like Lazare, but I find myself questioning the meaning of life a great deal.

I found solace in the knowledge that Zola wrote later in life that Lazare is a semi-autobiographical character of himself (particularly in his younger days), and in that sense, it shows that purpose and direction can be found in life, despite whatever personalities are handed down to us by nature and/or God.

I said that there is a lot of depression and despair in the novel, but it is a pleasure to read. Perhaps a slow burner, it nevertheless builds the characters and the emotions between them really well, and despite not being a thriller, there are passages that are indeed gripping. Pauline is a character you can’t help but root for throughout the novel, and her story is both tragic and inspiring at the same time.

It is often said that Zola’s novels in the Rougon-Macquart cycle can be read as stand-alone novels. I’m not sure I agree with this sentiment. I mean, of course you can read them how you like, but for me, a lot of the novels work especially well, and are further enhanced, because of their relationship and connection with other novels in the series.

Having said that, I believe The Bright Side of Life can be read as a stand-alone novel, as there are very few references to other characters and events in other novels. The few that there are do not need further background reading to understand this novel.

I’d highly recommend reading other titles in the Les Rougon-Macquart series as well, but if you are looking for a Zola novel, that can be read without prior knowledge of the other novels, involving a deep study of an isolated community, and in particular the tensions, frustrations and joy within a specific household, then The Bright Side of Life will fit nicely into your summer reading plan.

Quotes from The Bright Side of Life

“Evil and poverty went together, and she was never repelled by suffering, even when it seemed to be the consequence of vice. She simply expressed, with an expansive gesture of protest, her charitable tolerance.”

“Why should such an abomination as pain exist? Was not all such bodily torture, such twisting and burning of the muscles, monstrously pointless, when it was a poor girl’s body, so white and delicate, that the disease was attacking?”

“Suddenly she felt a sense of release, accompanied by deep pity for that unhappy woman, so consumed by fear and hatred.”

“Anyhow, he was one of those who never complain, whose ambition is satisfied when they have bread to eat and water to drink.”

“Why can’t you just live? Isn’t it enough to be alive? Joy comes from action.”

“From now on, this became Pauline’s great endeavour. She applied all her energy and ingenuity to making the household happy around her.”

“And a fine life that will be, for a woman like me! A real prison, without even the chance of going out and seeing anyone; and that stupid sea wherever you look, which seems to make the place even more boring….Oh! If only I’d known, if only!”

“What would there be left for her to do, if the household became too happy?”

Songs that will always remind me of reading The Bright Side of Life

Winter Song by Chris Rea

Sing a Song of Love to Me by Chris Rea

Mary Anne by Marshall Crenshaw

5 thoughts on “Thoughts On The Bright Side of Life by Émile Zola

  1. Your enlightening and insightful rundown of this ironically titled work of Zola’s made for interesting reading, Pete. You give this work coverage from a variety of angles. The connection with mental health and how great authors seem to be prescient at times in their presagement of the future is a pertinent point. I thought your identification of some parts of your own inner self with one of the characters was something that resonated. With all your getting get understanding is a good precept to follow from Proverbs and you typify that goal in your writings.

    Theodore Dreiser is an author that Zola’s work (what little I know of it-three novels of his I’ve read) reminds me of. Sister Carrie and An American Tragedy are pretty unremitting in their bleakness and a general air of hopelessness that prevails but were full of interest for me, long lugubrious books though they were.

    Happy Bloomsday/Birthday to you, Pete, on this doubly special day!

    Like

    1. Hi George, Thank you very much for your comments and thoughts, as always! Thank you so much as well for Birthday/Bloomsday wishes! I did think about writing a blog post on Bloomsday and my birthday, but I decided to capture my thoughts on ‘The Bright Side of Life’ instead, before I forgot them! I would love to blog more than I do, but I have to balance it up with a full time job and raising a near 1 year old, but if opportunity provides, I would love to blog more, especially on all classics.

      I turn 40 next year, so I’m saving Ulysses for reading during my 40th birthday, which is probably the earliest I have ever scheduled a book reading!

      You are absolutely right, ‘The Bright Side of Life’ is ironic, though I think Zola is joking as well, though there is a connection between the title, and the character of Pauline. Nietzsche used to joke a lot about Zola, and referred to this title ‘The Joy of Living’ (other english title) as ‘The Joy of Stinking’, I think in ‘Twilight of the Idols’. The joke being Zola’s unfortunate nearness of name to Gorgonzola cheese. This obviously used to tickle Nietzsche.

      Thank you for mentioning Theodore Dreiser, I will have to add that to the list of author’s I will look into. It sounds from my brief look that Dreiser’s style is naturalist, the same style Zola is famous for. I read somewhere that Zola was an influence on James Joyce as well, but I can’t the reference anymore. It would make sense though.

      It’s hard to admit sometimes when you see yourself in a certain character’s, especially the one as cynical as I mentioned (Lazare), but being able to identify your shortcomings (or lessons I would call them) is a key way to understanding yourself and being able to grow from there. I know I’m not cynical like Lazare, but in his struggle to find a ‘calling’, I definitely identify with.

      Thanks again for all your thoughts and comments. I really appreciate your contribution to this blog, and you give me much wisdom and authors to think about!

      Like

  2. Pete, I am always glad to see that you are willing to consider adding even more works to the formidable list you have established. It may eventually grow to as many as 400 or more at this rate. This in addition to the many valid demands on your time now of family and career, but at your present age you are at what some have called the flood-tide of life. I have full confidence in your capability to fully achieve any and all reading goals of yours.

    Like you say, Dreiser is what is called a naturalist as opposed to Proust, whose realism is that of the symbolist, who can also when he wishes, describe to perfection. As I mentioned, Dreiser’s novels take a long time to get through, but also leave a long-lasting impression on the reader who sticks with them. There is a poignant short-story of Dreiser’s titled “The Lost Phoebe”about the sad aftermath for the husband at the ending of a long-lasting marriage. While I don’t remember the details after many years, the moving impression stays with me which, I think, attests to the power of this writer.

    I liked the anecdote you gave about the joke Nietzche made concerning Zola’s title. Clifton Fadiman’s Little, Brown Book of Anecdotes provides a number of literary, historical and all-walks-of-life types of these.

    It’s interesting how we can relate to the something we may see of ourselves in characters from books, and also be fascinated by those such as Ian Fleming’s James Bond, when we don’t (speaking for myself) possess a trace of his suavity and derring-do ourselves. Part of the lure of escapist fiction, I guess. As a teen-ager, I would read and re-read the Bond novels, as well as books like Advise and Consent, and Gone With the Wind.

    It’s always a lot of fun to talk about books with you, Pete. Thanks as always for your encouragement.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Agree, it’s a charming, down-to-earth novel. No exaggeration or complex description, and Pauline is as “normal” as anyone can be. It’s honest and normal. I read this last year, here’s my review

    My only complain is the cover – it’s the ugliest of OWC edition of Zola, and it doesn’t reflect the book at all. I assume, that’s why you didn’t post it here? Anyway, it’s also interesting that Van Gogh chose this particular book to be painted in his “Still Life with Bible”. I have analyzed it in this post.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Fanda, No, I didn’t deliberately not include the cover, sometimes I include them, sometimes I don’t. I should probably get some consistency with this blog! The picture on the cover itself doesn’t bother me, but it doesn’t fit with the other covers in the Oxford Rougon-Macquart series. It was obviously used because the painting is called Le Joie de Vivre, but yeah, they should have thought of the style as well.

      I was aware of Van Gogh’s love of the novel, and his use of it in his paintings. I’m not an expert at analysing paintings and looking for deeper meaning in them, but I have had the pleasure to see Van Gogh’s work in the Musée D’Orsay, and was completely awe-inspired at knowing I was looking at the work of a genius.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s